Date of Degree
MS (Master of Science)
Occupational and Environmental Health
Nonnenmann, Matthew W.
First Committee Member
Second Committee Member
Infectious diseases account for over 15 million deaths worldwide. Those who are at greatest risk of contracting an infectious disease are immunocompromised. These individuals may be admitted to a healthcare-based setting where they may become infected. In the United States, 1.7 million immunocompromised individuals contract a healthcare-associated infection which lengthens stay, increases medical costs, and puts lives at stake. The transmission routes for these infections occur from direct contact with healthcare staff and contaminated surfaces. Indirect contact methods, such as bioaerosols suggest, but are not a well-examined route of infection. One possible bioaerosol generator includes the flushing of loose stools in toilets from infected patients. To date, no study has investigated the particle or bioaerosol changes in the air resulting from toilet flushing loose fecal wastes in a healthcare setting. The purpose of this study was to investigate changes in the air before and after a toilet flush to support hypotheses that toilets can produce an aerosol containing viable microorganisms, potentially spreading infectious disease.
Particle and bioaerosol concentrations were measured in hospital bathrooms across 3 sampling conditions; no waste no flush, no waste with flush, and fecal waste with flush. Particle concentrations were measured with a particle counter 3 minutes before a flushing event and throughout the bioaerosol collection period. Bioaerosol concentrations were measured with BioStage impactors fixed on a sampling cart at distances of 0.15, 0.5, and 1 m that was placed in front of a toilet. For each sampling trial, 3 time measurements were recorded after a flushing event (i.e., 5, 10, 15 minutes).
Particle concentrations measured before and after the flush were found to be significantly different in 0.3 (p-values= 0.002, 0.002, 0.015), 0.5 (p-values= 0.002, 0.002, 0.018), 1 (p-values= 0.003, 0.003, 0.027), and 3 µm (p-values= 0.016, 0.032) size bins of the no waste with flush and 0.3 (p-values= 0.009, 0.007, 0.007), 0.5 (p-values= 0.018, 0.006, 0.004), 1 µm (p-values= 0.023, 0.013,) size bins of the fecal waste with flush conditions. Bioaerosol concentrations measured in the no waste no flush and fecal waste with flush were found to be significantly different (p-value= 0.005). However, the bioaerosol concentrations measured were not significantly different across time (p-value= 0.977) or distance (p-value= 0.911).
From the study, we concluded that toilets in this unit produce particles when flushed. The particles aerosolized include microorganisms remaining from previous use or from loose fecal wastes. Differences in bioaerosol concentrations across conditions also suggest that toilets flushed containing wastes may be a likely source of bioaerosols that could allow transmission of infectious microorganisms. No observed differences across time and distance of bioaerosol concentrations suggests that generated aerosols quickly diffuse in the air. Since this study is the first to quantify particles and bioaerosols produced from flushing a hospital toilet, future studies are needed for comparison and for intervention development.
In the United States, 1.7 million people acquire an infection while in a healthcare- based care setting, and those at highest risk include immunocompromised individuals. Understanding sources of infectious microorganisms are important to implement protective controls to reduce transmission. Bioaerosols produced from flushing fecal wastes in healthcare settings are a potential source of infection that has not been investigated. The study objective was to investigate changes in particle and bioaerosol concentrations with flushes of hospital toilets containing fecal wastes.
Particle and bioaerosol concentrations were measured across 3 hospital bathroom conditions: no waste no flush, no waste with flush, and fecal waste with flush. Particle concentrations were compared before and after a toilet flush containing no waste and fecal waste to determine if toilets can generate particles. Bioaerosol concentrations were measured after a flush to compare across the 3 conditions. Bioaerosol concentrations were also measured at 3 set distances and time periods in front of the toilets.
Conditions where toilets were flushed had significant changes in the particle concentrations of 0.3, 0.5, 1, and 3 µm size bins (p-values< 0.05). Bioaerosol concentrations were significant across the no flush no waste and the fecal waste with flush conditions (p-value= 0.005). Time nor distance affected the bioaerosol concentrations (p-values> 0.05). The study suggests that particles and microorganisms can be aerosolized from flushing toilets, therefore future studies should focus on toilet flushing as a source of bioaerosols and create intervention practices to reduce environmental contamination and occupational exposures.
viii, 74 pages
Includes bibliographical references (pages 68-74).
Copyright © 2017 Samantha Dawn Knowlton
Knowlton, Samantha Dawn. "Measuring bioaerosol concentrations generated from toilet flushes during hospital-based patient care." MS (Master of Science) thesis, University of Iowa, 2017.